Another interesting Atkins court decision has been posted to the court decisions section of this blog. Jeffrey Williams (Williams v Quarterman, Texas, 2007). Augmenting this court decision is a copy of a psychological report included in the decision. An initial read of the decision and the psychological report raises a number of interesting questions and issues, such as:
Technorati Tags: psychology, forensic psychology, criminal psychology, neuropsychology, school psychology, educational psychology, MR, mental retardation, intellectual disabilitiy, developmental disability, intelligence, IQ, IQ scores, IQ tests, WAIS-III, SB V, SB5, Stanford Binet V, Atkins case, death penalty, capital punishment
- The apparent role of a judge becoming the psychometric expert when she decides which part score (verbal, nonverbal, full scale) to use to establish Williams level of intellectual functioning. Kevin Foley has provided a guest post about this issue, which will be the next post at this blog.
- The continued issue of part vs full scale IQ scores in Atkins cases.
- The role of school records and school special education decisions made during elementary and secondary schooling in Atkins decisions.
- The role of measured academic achievement in Atkins decisions, particularly the issue of whether a person who may be mentally retarded can achieve above their measured IQ (note - I've written about this previously and will make comments with appropriate links in a separate post..the answer is "yes").
- The conceptually and technically messy issue of determining pre-incarceration levels of adaptive behavior retrospectively. I'm hoping that a few experts in Atkins AB assessment will review the documents and weigh in on the information provided, expert opinions, and final decision. This area is a definite methodological quagmire in Atkins cases.
- The whole issue of malingering and how to detect it
Technorati Tags: psychology, forensic psychology, criminal psychology, neuropsychology, school psychology, educational psychology, MR, mental retardation, intellectual disabilitiy, developmental disability, intelligence, IQ, IQ scores, IQ tests, WAIS-III, SB V, SB5, Stanford Binet V, Atkins case, death penalty, capital punishment