Wednesday, May 28, 2014

Hall v. Florida Impact: 20 Cases? [feedly]

Hall v. Florida Impact: 20 Cases?
// Crime and Consequences Blog

How many cases will yesterday's decision in Hall v. Florida actually impact?  Lizette Alvarez and John Schwartz have this article in the NYT estimating "10 to 20," citing anti-death-penalty law professor John Blume for that estimate.  (The article doesn't identify Blume as an advocate for one side on this issue, but he is.) "The death row inmates in this category would generally have I.Q.'s of between 71 and 75. Inmates in that category should now be able to ask for a new hearing that would take into consideration other evidence and a broader range of I.Q. tests."

There are a couple of points to note here.  First, it appears a prominent advocate for the other side implicitly agrees that Hall does not require reconsideration in cases where the inmate's test scores are above 75.  My prior post and the comments to it discussed whether Hall might extend to murderers whose scores are consistently above 75.  I don't think it does yet -- and apparently Blume agrees -- though the Court may still go there in the future.

Does everyone in the 71 to 75 twilight zone automatically get a new hearing?  If that means evidentiary hearing, I don't think so.  Hall himself, for example, put on the experts who testified to the same thing they would testify to after the Supreme Court's decision.  I don't see any reason why the trial judge cannot enter a new decision on the same record, considering the margin of error as the Supreme Court directs.  I expect his decision would be the same.  The state might want a new evidentiary hearing to put on the evidence it didn't think was necessary before, but Hall has already had his shot.


Shared via my feedly reader

Article: Justice Alito’s Statistics Lesson Misses the Mark in Recent Dissent, Experts Say

Justice Alito's Statistics Lesson Misses the Mark in Recent Dissent, Experts Say

Sent via Flipboard

Blogmaster, Dr. Kevin McGrew, participates in Huffington Post live stream interview this morning: WATCH: Death Row Inmates With Low IQs Get 2nd Chance

Thought you might enjoy this video:

Death Row Inmates With Low IQs Get 2nd Chance

In a 5-4 decision on Tuesday, the US Supreme Court struck down Florida's IQ execution law, which was used to determine mentally disabled inmates' eligibility for execution, calling it "unconstitutional."

Wednesday, May 21, 2014

CHC theory 101: \"Big picture\" context and from Spearman's g to contemporary CHC - new SlideShare modules

A was shared with you
Hi Kevin,

Share Your Uploads With Your Network.

Do more with your uploads with our Tip of the Day
CHC theory 101:  Introduction to "big pict...
CHC theory 101: Introduction to "big pict...
Share:  Share  Share  Share 
This is a brief introduction for placing...Edit info
View now
CHC theory 101:  From general intelligence...
CHC theory 101: From general intelligence...
Share:  Share  Share  Share 
The second in the CHC Theory 101 series....Edit info
View now

Share Get featured on the homepage – select a trending topic, make it visual and add a powerful headline to increase chances of getting featured. Learn more.


From SlideShare, A LinkedIn Company
We send you these emails to help you get the most out of SlideShare.
You can change your email preferences or unsubscribe from SlideShare emails anytime.
© 2014 LinkedIn Corporation, 1 Montgomery Street, Suite 1300, San Francisco, CA, 94104, USA